UTI Misdiagnosis: A Growing Problem in American Healthcare
`
A common error in American healthcare involves older individuals who exhibit confusion, fatigue, dizziness, loss of appetite, or stumbles.
These typical geriatric symptoms often lead to a standard response: a urine test to check for a urinary tract infection.
However, this is frequently an incorrect assumption.
The UTI has become a common, often inaccurate, diagnosis when an elderly person presents vague health issues without the primary symptom of painful urination. As a geriatrician, I urge healthcare providers to focus on identifying the true causes of these problems instead of routinely ordering urine tests.
UTIs are a widespread health concern, with millions of diagnoses worldwide annually. In the U.S., they account for numerous doctor visits and millions of emergency room treatments each year. A significant portion of the population will experience at least one UTI in their lifetime, with diagnosis rates increasing with age, particularly after 65.
Numerous global studies have highlighted the overdiagnosis of UTIs, including a large hospital study in 2020, cases across multiple hospitals in Michigan, and significant percentages of diagnosed patients in California studies published in 2022.
Misdiagnosing UTIs leads to unnecessary antibiotic use, particularly in older individuals, increasing the risk of gut infections, antibiotic resistance, and failure to address the underlying causes of geriatric syndromes.
The lack of geriatric training contributes to this issue. Despite an aging population, the number of certified geriatricians has decreased. Many physicians lack expertise in treating older patients.
Most family practice and internal medicine doctors receive limited training in geriatric care. A small percentage of medical schools require geriatric rotations compared to pediatric rotations, as highlighted in a recent study. Consequently, many doctors are unaware of the challenges in treating older individuals. A survey revealed a significant rate of improper UTI diagnoses among healthcare professionals.
Technical factors also contribute to misdiagnosis. Frail older individuals often struggle to provide sterile urine samples, requiring specific cleaning and collection techniques. Contamination is common, leading to unreliable results.
Additionally, many older adults have complex conditions and carry bacteria in their bladders without infection, known as asymptomatic bacteriuria. While most with this condition do not develop symptomatic UTIs, they are often treated with antibiotics unnecessarily, causing more harm than good.
Therefore, many urine samples are either contaminated or test positive for reasons other than UTIs.
While genuine UTIs exist and pose a risk of sepsis in the elderly, healthcare professionals should avoid automatically diagnosing UTIs. A thorough medical history, vital sign assessment, examination, bloodwork, consideration of other causes, and close monitoring are crucial to avoid overlooking serious infections.
Ordering a urine test is simple, but it is not always the appropriate course of action.